I tend to have a knack of watching anime at really poignant times in my life. After just getting out of high school was when I first watched Azumanga Daioh. While it was an amazing show which is an enduring favorite to this day, its ending still made me depressed that that period of my life was over. Four years later I suppose I should have known what I was getting into when I started watched Honey and Clover, the story of a boy going through his college days with good friends. It’s at the tail end of Honey and Clover that I was looking for something, anything to cheer me up and brighten my mood. It was then, scrolling through Hulu’s surprisingly robust selection of shows that I rolled over a gag series I’d only heard of in passing, that of the hilarious escapades of Sgt. Frog.
A lot of what I find to be the defining trait that makes a comedy good is a terrific cast of characters, and Sgt. Frog is no exception. The eponymous Sgt. Frog, a consummate ne’er-do-well, absolutely makes the show. His incompetence and laziness always result in him finding the most elaborate and amusing ways to ditch his duties or get more money for his gigantic Gundam model collection. Eventually joining him is the ever faithful Tamama, a cutesy soldier with a mean jealousy streak; Giroro, a hardened fighter and fish out of water in a platoon full of lunatics; Kululu, a mad scientist whose sadistic tendencies are a main driver of physical comedy; and Dororo, a quiet ninja who has sworn off the crazy group for his own safety. Each character really plays off the others well and show how incompetent this earth invading squadron is in the most ludicrous fashion.
Supporting the platoon is a group of humans who has decided to take the frogs in as they are scattered from a botched invasion attempt. The members of the Hinata household are the main supporting characters and their house is the seat of most of the action. Dorky Fuyuki and fiery Natsumi have a great dynamic as brother and sister. However, I usually feel they are underused and seem primarily in the show to react or be victims to the antics of the ARMPIT platoon. Their mom is by far the most exploited character in the show, with most every scene involving some kind of fanservice. By far my favorite human character is the lovecrazed Momoka, the guardian of Tamama, who steals every scene with her wild internal monologs and hilariously exaggerated obsession.
The entire cast is rounded out by two great additions which I really think change the show from simply funny to outright hilarious. Throughout many episodes there is a narrator who often interacts with members of the cast. He is the source of great back-and-forth scenes that really add to the light-hearted insanity of the show. I also love the liberties taken in the English dub with translating the scrolling text. By either making offhand comments on the show as it’s unfolding or even refusing to properly translate what it is saying, it’s given it a personality all its own. It can suffer from the Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei effect of too much text too quickly to analyze it all, but it is not very common and usually everything it has to say is given plenty of time to read.
With a cast of alien frogmen bent on taking over the world, it’s easy to tell that Sgt. Frog is an absurdist comedy. Much of the humor comes off of the banter between characters as they deal with whatever messed up situation the Sergeant has gotten them into today. I cannot stress how much of a better experience this is made by watching the English dub. There’s a lot of care gone into the writing here to maximize jokes for an American audience. While I do enjoy it when it is executed well, referential humor can really fall flat if it is too localized. I loved the gag dub of Ghost Stories, but when I watched it back in 08 many of the references, like Christian Slater’s acting career, really fell flat because I barely knew what they were talking about. While Sgt. Frog inherently benefits from current events not being too stale since it was just made in 2009, there are a lot of well executed references to timeless pieces of pop culture. While Sgt. Frog has a lot to offer, it isn’t perfect by any means. There are many episodes where the comedy lasts throughout the entire length of the show, some episodes fall flat, or have punchlines that take way too long to capitalize on.
I may have been spoiled by Nichijou’s flawless style, but as a typical comedy show, especially one that was animated back in 04, there isn’t much to say of Sgt. Frog’s technical values. Frames will often be reused and even if done for comic relief it can become boring to watch the same scenes or simply look at a still of the Serge talking as he lazes about. Since it doesn’t really gain anything from better definition this does at least make it quite an easy decision if you’re strapped on cash to simply
check the show out on Hulu.
Despite some flaws, I obviously enjoyed Sgt. Frog. It has a great cast and a fantastic sense of humor. I would definitely consider it with the likes of Azumanga Daioh or Cromartie High as one of the best comedies I've ever had the pleasure to watch.