Quantcast
First Impressions: Girls und Panzer - JAPANATOR
DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist


REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll


First Impressions: Girls und Panzer


8:45 PM on 10.18.2012
First Impressions: Girls und Panzer photo



Girls und Panzer

Girls and Tanks.

It's a very simple concept, but in the culture of mecha musume and moe anthropomorphism, where practically anything can be turned into a cute girl (or boy), there are many ways to execute on it.

Girls und Panzer knows this, and spends much of the first two episodes showing just which path they're taking on the long, glorious (?) road of associating armored warfare with underage schoolgirls.

[Please note - It may be hard for me to talk about this without coming across as some kind of person with conservative views on gender politics. Not true at all!]

See, Girls und Panzer's path is not that of the gender reversal. And I'm not talking about the well-worn chestnut of this- boy-is-now-a-girl gender-swapping, or the equally well-worn trap/reverse-trap dichotomy. Instead, Girls und Panzer is a little less overt, and one might say profound about it. It's about gender roles, see.

And it's not in the Infinite Stratos-esque, everything-is-topsy-turvy-haha-girls-doing-boy-things kind of way - that's only there because most viewers will hold those prejudices. Rather, in the world of Girls und Panzer, this uber-boyish thing to do, namely mechanized warfare, was always a girly thing to do, or at least has been so long that it is inconceivable that boys would bother with it. 

It's not even a tomboy thing. The girls all still act like girls (anime girls, at least), tittering and giggling at the thought of boys driving tanks in the same way they might titter and giggle (they're too young/innocent to swoon) at the thought of boys wearing frilly dresses. Rather than ignoring the seemingly inherent girlishness of an activity or aesthetic, as Busou Shinki does, Girls und Panzer boldly lumps the World of Tanks into the same class as tea parties, crochet, Lisa Frank binders, and My Little Pony (pre-Friendship is Magic). In this world, tank warfare is one of the keys to growing up as a proper lady.

There's even an argument to be made for Girls und Panzer having somewhat progressive views on certain gender roles. Rather than the typical otaku-bait of quiet, almost subservient Yamato Nadeshiko archetypes or the hysterics and and predictable contradiction of the tsundere, the propaganda films promoting Sensha-dou (literally "Way of the Tank") state proudly that tank-driving turns girls into women, and develops the qualities that all the boys go wild for. Qualities like strength, independence, and the ability to command a mothef*cking tank in a motherf*cking tank battle. Shit, man, I would go wild for that kind of woman.

Anyway, back to Girls und Panzer's chosen moe moe machinations. If it's not quite tapping the same vein as Infinite Stratos or Busou Shinki, is it drawing from the school of Strike Witches, Hetalia, or Upotte? Not quite, seeing as the girls themselves are for all intents and purposes, normal. "Anime" normal, but normal. They see das Panzerfahren as a pastime or hobby, like someone would see painting, sculpture, sports, flower-arranging, videogames, or any other Thing That You Have Fun Doing. In fact, to them armored warfare is a fairly traditional, old-fashioned subject, in a league with tea ceremonies and etiquette classes.

Of course, you might be wondering what the difference between this and any other "cute girls have a hobby club" anime, like Saki or a sports anime. Well, this has tanks, for one. Games like mahjong and sports (even, say, shooting) don't quite carry the same gender-role baggage as tank-driving. Weirdly, it seems that this world is familiar with these tanks actual history, referencing Rommel, the Blitz, and World War II in general. Unless the entire war was genderswapped in this alternate universe, the world still remembers a time when tanking was the sole province of men. Strange, that.

Further, this has real-life tanks, ones that existed in Real True History. That's the difference between this, and, say, if the girls all just drove fictional mecha. The tanks of World War II were monsters to operate. Being in one would be like working inside an oven rolling down a hill while being shot at. And these high-schoolers with strangely large heads are driving M3 Lees, Panzer IV's, Churchills, Mathildas, StuGs, Type-89s, and Panzer 38(t)s around as if they were horses in dressage.

The show cleverly plays up realism in the right ways. Because the tanks are real tanks with presumably accurate interiors and appearances (minus the pink paintjobs and flags and other girly accouterments), the girls are barely big enough to fit at their stations, the commanders' legs too short to deliver steering instructions in the traditional manner (by kicking the driver in the shoulders). It's especially hilarious watching six middle school-sized chicks running the Lee. It's like watching an armored clown car.

Ultimately, this is a fan service show, though catering more to military nerds than folks looking for boobs and upskirts. Girls und Panzer has been fairly tame thus far, barring a wet t-shirt and a swimsuit. Given the kids' proportions, I'm hoping it stays that way. 

More general fans of cute-girls shows may find a few bones tossed their way as well, with a few feel-good friendship moments that border on touching. Plus, the seeds for future drama have been planted, mainly in Miho's traumatic tank-driving history. There's a good amount of potential in this one, if the show can keep with its own premise rather than devolve into yet another girls-club show.

Also, the girls' school and entire town rest on the deck of a city-sized Yorktown-class Shokaku-class aircraft carrier, making it basically the greatest anime ever made.

[Watch chicks in tanks on The Anime Network]






Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.


7:00 AM on 06.19.2013

Shonen Showdown 6-19-2013

It's time once more for the battle anime and manga recap that you love, Shonen Showdown! And yes, though the header may not quite show our reaction face, it loves you too! In fact, our love is so strong that we've jumped...

Josh Tolentino

4:00 PM on 06.18.2013

OreImo 2's last episodes to be streamed worldwide

Oh that greedy imouto! We're already approaching the end of OreImo 2's TV run, but in true "modern anime industry" fashion, there are to be several more episodes intended to round the story out at a sweet sixteen outings...

Josh Tolentino

5:00 PM on 06.17.2013

License Burst: Viz reveals their goods for Licensing Expo

After keeping track of so many Viz related news, I think it's safe to say that I have become the Viz guy for J-tor. Continuing with my ongoing duty under my new unofficial title, I'm here to let you know that Viz is going to ...

Salvador G-Rodiles

3:00 PM on 06.17.2013

New Captain Harlock trailer in all its Space Opera glory

If you've been on the fence about the upcoming Captain Harlock movie, I'm betting that this hot new trailer is going to sell you on it. The upcoming remake of the Leiji Matsumoto classic from 1970 sports a record breaking 30...

Hiroko Yamamura

2:00 PM on 06.17.2013

Are you lady? iDOLM@STER film hits late 2013

Things have been quiet ever since The iDOLM@STER feature film was announced a while back. Details are still light, but at least we have a time frame for release. The movie is set to hit Japanese theaters at the end of 2013, i...

Elliot Gay

12:00 PM on 06.17.2013

Movic preparing new jackets based on Evangelion 3.0

Love it or hate it, Evangelion 3.0: You Can (Not) Redo certainly surprised a lot of folks. It also made a whole lot of money. Like any good money making property, Eva 3.0 merchandise has been hitting the market at a consisten...

Elliot Gay

8:00 AM on 06.17.2013

Neptunia TV anime gets some big advertising

After what feels like years of writing about Compile Heart's Neptunia games, I'm actually in the process of playing one for a review. It feels like my entire career has come full circle or something. This Thursday marks the r...

Elliot Gay

6:00 AM on 06.17.2013

New One Piece Film Z BD/DVD TV ad is sweet sauce

One Piece Film Z is pretty spectacular. As far as One Piece films go, this one ranks very highly for me, especially due to its top notch action choreography and beautiful animation. As a bonus, the story is cool in the way i...

Elliot Gay

6:00 PM on 06.14.2013

The first 8 minutes of Ghost in the Shell Arise rise up

Hankering for another dose of Ghost in the Shell and schlocky Microsoft Surface promos aren't enough to do the job? Bandai and Production IG have just the thing for you! How about eight full minutes of Ghost in the Shell Ari...

Josh Tolentino

2:00 PM on 06.14.2013

Toothbrush time! Aniplex licenses Monogatari S2, Nekokuro

Rejoice, fans of licensing acquisitions, for another one of those has happened! In a move that's sure to delight fans of the Monogatari franchise, Aniplex of America has announced their pickup of the latest two Monogata...

Josh Tolentino




Facebook Shares





From other sites around the web
















Back to Top



Advertising on Japanator is available: Please contact them to learn more