Quantcast
First Impressions: Minami-ke Tadaima - JAPANATOR
DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist


REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll


First Impressions: Minami-ke Tadaima


12:00 PM on 01.13.2013
First Impressions: Minami-ke Tadaima photo



I remember Minami-ke. According to my MAL account, I watched it a little while after it came out in April of 2008. It was one of the first slice-of-life shows I watched, and I definitely enjoyed my time with it. The sequels came out after some time, but similarly to many other fans, I found they didn't really hold the same quality as the original.

So here we are with the fourth iteration. I've heard from some people that this is meant to be a return to form, but you know, I can't say I'm going in particularly optimistic. I mean, the second and third series weren't exactly terrible, but having to watch another of those is certainly not what I'm looking for right now.

Please be good. 

Minami-ke has one of the most simple plots going; three sisters go about their school lives. It's a comedy, so there should be plenty of scenes here and there that will give you a good giggle, rather than full on drama or anything like that. We have the eldest sister, Haruka, who is the most responsible of the trio and pretty much acts like a surrogate mother to the other two. Kana, the sister in the middle, is the happy-go-lucky idiot of the three. Chiaki, the youngest, is the one who is too smart for her age. She adores Haruka, but thinks Kana is just a bumbling idiot. Accurate. 

One of the most common complaints about the Minami-ke anime is that the quality suffered after the animation studio changed after the first season. The original anime was produced by Daume (whose last anime was Shiki in 2010), where it was then passed to Asread (who tend to do additional animation for other companies) for two seasons and an OVA, and finally to Feel, who're doing this series and an OVA. We have a nice and fresh face, so everything is looking good!

See, this is the part where I would start recapping the show, but can I even do that? It's hard enough covering slice-of-life shows without just transcribing an episode, and to make matters worse, I feel like I've already seen this episode.

To clear things up, let me iterate that no, I haven't seen this episode before. On the same point, all of the jokes felt incredibly recycled. The kotatsu jokes are back, Kana is still an idiot/beetle, Chiaki still thinks Kana is an idiot... the list goes on. The problem is that this is the entire point. This is Minami-ke. You could expect this kind of thing from any sequel to a slice-of-life show.

There were some new things, granted. I don't remember a few of the characters, so I'm pretty sure some of them are new additions. We got to see Chiaki's conscience. We even got to see Haruka act lazy. But... it doesn't matter. At least, not to me. I just couldn't find it funny. 

I'm certainly finding this pretty strange. As I mentioned earlier, I didn't have high hopes going in, but the opening music certainly reassured me that things might just be alright after all. It's not a reused track, but it does have that classic singing of 'Minami-ke', which I have to say got me a little hyped up and nostalgic. A good move, that's for sure.

Minami-ke isn't bad, not by a long shot. I don't even think it's a lack of effort or jokes in the show itself. So, I'm saying it. It's not the anime, it's me. I think after four years of waiting on a good sequel and watching constant lacklustre efforts has really just put me off the show as a whole. This may indeed be the season that die-hard fans have been waiting for, and more power to them, but I think I'm done. I just don't think I can enjoy this show any more. I also think this will be the case if I went back to the original series.

So, how do I conclude all of that? If you liked the original series, you should love this. If you liked the sequels, you will love this. If you are tired of the series, perhaps you should pass. I'll give it a few episodes just to make sure it doesn't invigorate my past adoration of the first season, but I'm not hopeful. Anyone else stuck like this, or are you all enjoying it?






Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.


11:02 PM on 06.19.2013

Little Witch Academia getting a collector's edition in NA

Not too long ago, we reported that Trigger would be bringing their phenomenal half hour animated film, Little Witch Academia, to BD. There weren't a whole lot of details to be shared. Until now. The Little Witch Academia Col...

Elliot Gay

7:00 PM on 06.19.2013

Screening Impact! Eva 3.0 to get a US premiere at JFFSF

The Japan Film Festival of San Francisco can't help but to expand its roster of films before the main event continues its rampage from July 27th through August 4th. Now that FUNi has the inevitable rights to Eva 3.0, the film...

Salvador G-Rodiles

7:00 AM on 06.19.2013

Shonen Showdown 6-19-2013

It's time once more for the battle anime and manga recap that you love, Shonen Showdown! And yes, though the header may not quite show our reaction face, it loves you too! In fact, our love is so strong that we've jumped...

Josh Tolentino

4:00 PM on 06.18.2013

OreImo 2's last episodes to be streamed worldwide

Oh that greedy imouto! We're already approaching the end of OreImo 2's TV run, but in true "modern anime industry" fashion, there are to be several more episodes intended to round the story out at a sweet sixteen outings...

Josh Tolentino

5:00 PM on 06.17.2013

License Burst: Viz reveals their goods for Licensing Expo

After keeping track of so many Viz related news, I think it's safe to say that I have become the Viz guy for J-tor. Continuing with my ongoing duty under my new unofficial title, I'm here to let you know that Viz is going to ...

Salvador G-Rodiles

3:00 PM on 06.17.2013

New Captain Harlock trailer in all its Space Opera glory

If you've been on the fence about the upcoming Captain Harlock movie, I'm betting that this hot new trailer is going to sell you on it. The upcoming remake of the Leiji Matsumoto classic from 1970 sports a record breaking 30...

Hiroko Yamamura

2:00 PM on 06.17.2013

Are you lady? iDOLM@STER film hits late 2013

Things have been quiet ever since The iDOLM@STER feature film was announced a while back. Details are still light, but at least we have a time frame for release. The movie is set to hit Japanese theaters at the end of 2013, i...

Elliot Gay

12:00 PM on 06.17.2013

Movic preparing new jackets based on Evangelion 3.0

Love it or hate it, Evangelion 3.0: You Can (Not) Redo certainly surprised a lot of folks. It also made a whole lot of money. Like any good money making property, Eva 3.0 merchandise has been hitting the market at a consisten...

Elliot Gay

8:00 AM on 06.17.2013

Neptunia TV anime gets some big advertising

After what feels like years of writing about Compile Heart's Neptunia games, I'm actually in the process of playing one for a review. It feels like my entire career has come full circle or something. This Thursday marks the r...

Elliot Gay

6:00 AM on 06.17.2013

New One Piece Film Z BD/DVD TV ad is sweet sauce

One Piece Film Z is pretty spectacular. As far as One Piece films go, this one ranks very highly for me, especially due to its top notch action choreography and beautiful animation. As a bonus, the story is cool in the way i...

Elliot Gay




Facebook Shares





From other sites around the web
















Back to Top



Advertising on Japanator is available: Please contact them to learn more