DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist

2:00 PM on 01.08.2010   |   Brad Rice

First Impressions: So Ra No Wo To photo

Summary: Yep, you're going to think of K-ON! again. And not in the good way.

We've got a chipper, energetic, and pretty damn forgetful girl who wants to learn about music. So what does she do? Enlist in the army. As I continued to watch the show, I got the strong feeling that this is going to be Yui Goes To War.

For those who watched K-ON!, a lot of this is going to feel familiar. Character archetypes, the faces (oh god, the faces) and the moe are more than abundant. I had my fill of over-abundant moe after K-ON!, and so I had a lot of trouble stomaching this show. Or writing about it, for that matter.

Follow me after the jump, and you'll see what I mean.

The plot of the first episode should be simple enough. Get from Point A to Point B in a certain amount of time. Not that hard, really. And yet, in her Yui-esque idiocy, Kanata manages to not only fail at this task, but also nearly kills herself. Great.

The premise of the show, beyond Yui Goes To War, is that Kanata has joined up with the buglers of the 1221st regiment in the town of Seize, and wants to learn how to play. She's god-awful at it to begin with, but over the course of 13 episodes, I'm sure we'll see her progress quite a bit.

Life seems to be at ease for most: the town has carefree celebrations and the military, in all its progressive glory, doesn't want rank to interfere with the friendship built between these girls. Clearly, friendship is more important than running an effective squad.

My point is this: the amount of moe pandering in this show is palpable. I swear, some of it leaked out of my monitor while watching this show. If you're fine with that sort of pandering, then you'll love this show. I had my fill of it with K-ON!, and so my hand is hovering over the drop button at this point in time.

What's kept me from forgetting this show entirely are the gorgeous visuals. The quality of animation, the colors used and the sheer amount of detail in the shots -- they could have all been postcard stills.

So, while I sit here and stew in my moe-induced rage, I can't bring myself to give the show the axe just yet. I'll wait a while, to see if the plot develops into something more, and hope that the war theme gets tackled a bit more directly. Who knows, it could surprise me.


First Impressions: So Ra No Wo To photo
First Impressions: So Ra No Wo To photo
First Impressions: So Ra No Wo To photo
First Impressions: So Ra No Wo To photo


MOAR top stories:




Legacy Comments

I'm confused to whether you hated it or recommend it in a "So bad, It's good" way. Whichever it is I'm still living a K-ON! free life so I'll probably look at that before I even consider this.

Now to decide which show has a dumber premise. The one with catgirl samurais or the one with trumpeting soldiers.
Not recommending it thus far. It's cold and slimy, but I'm giving it another episode before I drop it.
The thing about K-ON! was that it had a certain knowing charm. It knew how dumb it was and took every opportunity to be silly and funny and totally inconsequential. Here it sounds like they've tipped that balance into pandering idiocy. I'll still give it a shot.
Wow, most people Ive talk to are comparing it to Haibane and Kino, which of course are huge complements. The score was wonderful, the backgrounds beautiful, the characters likable, and the promise of an intriguing storyline was set up as well. It's a damn shame you couldn't see past the K-on!/moe hang-up you seem to have to see what was really going on with this show.
@Rinshu That's why I'm not dropping it yet. I hear those comparisons, and I say "ok, show me what you've got." First episode did not hook me at all, though.
Compliments that is.
Yeah, I'm pretty much staying for the scenery porn.
Hoping for a Nice Boat last episode
Wow, I couldn't disagree with you more, Brad. I loved the first episode of this show.
It's kinda meh so far, but I see the potential for greatness
its looks REALLY GOOD!
I thought the first episode was a bit boring but not enough to make me drop it. I'll continue to watch it in hopes the story picks up and we get some pew-pew in this moe-filled world.

I hope we get to see that tank in action.
I'll take scenery fanservice over unnecessary panty shot any day
When someone dies. I will watch this war.
Still not interested, when all these moe soldiers kill their moe friends in the name of a moe cause, that's when I'll perk my ears up and start listening.
Ok, watched the first episode. I didn't think it was as bad as some are saying. It probably won't be up there with kimi no todoke, but it seems no worse then the average slice of life series.
Not interested. Now if characters start dying as they portray the tolls of war on the mindsets of the people, then I'll start checking it out.

I will admit though, that is some fine scenery porn.
Ugh, we've had enough "war is evil" shows. I'm hoping this series portrays the military in a positive light, instead of simply stereotyping them as an evil bureaucratic war machine.
ah. well, I'll have to give this a shot somehow.
It'd be fun to see how in the beginning all the characters are really high-energy and innocent, though as the story progresses and the war begins to take it's toll, they slowly go from that to manic, scared and traumatized. I'd say it'd be an interesting way to turn the whole 'moe slice of life' trend on it's head.
@Moonlight. If they can do that, it will be the greatest thing since Reena shouted 嘘だ! (usoda!)
I was somewhat suprised by this. I went into it expecting a clean copy of K-On, but what I got felt somewhat unique. Not to mention although early screenshots had me skeptical, the actual artwork is amazing at times, which is always a plus.

However, I'm guessing it's going to quickly go down the K-On route quickly with the "BFF" stuff. Hopefully not, and hopefully it'll have a more intriguing story, some elements of the first episode could prove promising yet.


Facebook Shares





Around the web