Now that we're a few weeks into the fall season, almost all of the shows have had time to air with most well into their 3rd week of episodes. Dunno about you guys, but some how I've managed to end up watching a LOT more than I had originally guessed I would. With the exception of the few at the bottom that still haven't aired yet, here's what my current list looks like (circles are watching, X's are not, ?'s are mehbehs):

That's currently 10 shows on top of a few others that I'm watching from previous seasons/waiting to be subbed/ongoing. Setokai will probably be dropped after 3 gets subbed, the push for humor just doesn't do anything for me, and Sacred Blacksmith is.... well, not doing very much to hold my attention. Sasameki Koto is also failing to hold me; for being lesbians, there is not enough going on! D:
By far, the highlight so far has been Kimi ni Todoke. First two episodes have been AMAZING, filled with both humor and DAAAWWWW moments, bad for my fucking heart. Any show that can bring you to tears in the first episode is working some mad voodoo magic... and I only hope they can keep it up. Evidently it was a manga... haven't read it, but heard it was great.
As for the rest, Kampfer's been great so far, along with Nyan Koi. Another notable mention would be the second season of Natsu no Arashi; the first one didn't do much for me, but the second one has started with gun blazing. The second White Album, on the other hand, has done little to impress. I remember being so FUCKING pissed last season when they left it as a cliffhanger for an entire YEAR. But so far, I'm more pissed at myself for waiting on this then I am at the show.
And before it gets brought up: no, I'm not watching the second season of Darker than Black. I couldn't make it through the first one.
So, how bout you guys? Have your lists for this season finalized yet?
Also, long time lurker, first time poster. Been around the 3 sites of the community for... around half a year now, finally decided to join. Nice to meet you all :D
I read the Fiary Tail manga and I love it but the anime has poor animation, the magic cirles are not needed(they were not in the manga) and the fights are weird. Still, I'll give it a chance since I love the manga and it features three great seiyu.
I originally started Nyan Koi, Kampfer and Shin Koihime Musou but I didn't enjoy them.