Quantcast
Jake Adelstein exposes NatGeo's exposure of yakuza - JAPANATOR
DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist


REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll


Jake Adelstein exposes NatGeo's exposure of yakuza


6:00 PM on 03.07.2011
Jake Adelstein exposes NatGeo's exposure of yakuza photo



Tokyo Vice author, video game reviewer and journalistic bad-ass Jake Adelstein has recently tore National Geographic Television a new one over what he sees as reckless endangerment of sources. He was part of NGT's new documentary on yakuza, something Adelstein has become something of an authority on.

Trouble is, Adelstein is a man of his word, much like those more ruthless types he covers. So when NGT did a bait and switch and changed their “factual accuracy” approach to “general accuracy”, possibly putting lives at risk, Adelstein sent all of NGT’s money back and asked to have his name completely removed from the project.

“I would rather lose my life savings than have anyone lose their life or their fingers for the entertainment of NGT’s viewers,” Adelstein says in this in-depth run-down of the situation. Calling what the NGT crew did “parachute journalism” aka jumping into a situation with no understanding of the larger issues at hand, he points out the cultural and societal differences between what one’s “word” means to someone like a member of the yakuza versus “an LA based ‘film director.”’


“Would I believe the word of three yakuza over the word of an LA based ‘film director’ who brags about his reputation for doing awesome ‘dramatizations’ and ‘re-creations’? Mmm…Yes. I’d believe the yakuza every time, in this case. The yakuza do have standards and practices. They are not particularly high standards but they exist.”


That’s just the tip of the iceberg. Adelstein’s article is gigantic, full of documentation, the conversation spilling well on into the comments. Much like his book, it’s a fascinating read and a rare insight into the real, unromanticized world of the yakuza and the press.






Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.

Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


I hope the higher-ups at national geographic will do the right thing and place the safety of the individuals involved over potential ratings.
I read one of Adelstein's interviews with a yakuza a while ago and was very impressed with the insight and realism that it was written.

I'm surprised and disappointed that National Geographic, who is long old and respected, would engage in shoddy journalism, disregarding the work of one of their own for potential ratings the easy way rather than the right way.
Journalistic integrity is always a welcome sight.
Did you get a comment from National Geographic for this piece?
Tokyo Vice was a great book and I hope everything works out for Mr. Adelstein.

On that note, a lot of the focus seems to be on journalistic integrity and protecting sources, but I would venture that there is a another reason for Mr. Adelstein's outrage. Professional survival.

If you live in Japan long enough, you begin to realize that your social/economic/professional survival doesn't hinge on just doing a good job and following the rules. It all hinges on relationships. The relationships you have can secure a position at a good company, introduce you to the right people and generally make your life easier. How you maintain those relationships has a marked result on how people look at you and speaks volumes on whether you are to be trusted or not.

In a society like Japan, one that values its privacy and has a clear idea of group dynamics, violated trust can pretty much be the death knell for a career. Especially if you're a gaikokujin, whom they look on with a certain level of skepticism anyway. Mr. Adelstein may very well be in damage control mode for his carefully cultivated relationships that have provided a lucrative career.

NatGeo basically may screw him every way from Sunday without even realizing it.
People can die because of a horribly done documentary.

Well done, NGT.

11:23 PM on 05.15.2013

Edgeworth and co looking swag in these new AA:DD screens

Despite yesterday's flood of Ace Attorney: Dual Destinies (AA5 in Japan) info and, it looks like things aren't over yet. The official Japanese website has updated to include profiles for Edgeworth, Trucy, and new detective Go...

Elliot Gay

7:48 PM on 05.15.2013

New Shin Megami Tensei IV trailer is a right of passage

The Japanese release of Shin Megami Tensei IV looms just over the horizon. For you folks out west, the game is scheduled to release on July 16. The western hype machine has started rolling, and Atlus is pumping out English t...

Elliot Gay

9:00 AM on 05.14.2013

Huzzah! Sen no Kiseki finally has a Japanese release date

The sixth mainline game in Falcom's Kiseki series (Trails in the Sky) has finally received a Japanese release date.  Eiyuu Densetsu: Sen no Kiseki will hit the PS3 and Vita on September 26 of this year. This falls in lin...

Elliot Gay

8:00 AM on 05.14.2013

This Attack on Titan mock film poster is pretty sweet

I have very little faith in the Japanese film industry's ability to make a decent live action adaptation of Attack on Titan. Very few studios here could supply the budget required to make it work. This is especially the case ...

Elliot Gay

4:00 AM on 05.11.2013

Tokyo ESP manga to get an anime adaptation

I have no idea if anybody out there is reading it, but Hajime Segawa's  Tokyo ESP is a lot of fun. The first arc stars a high school girl named Rinka, a poor girl who ends up developing super powers that allow her t...

Elliot Gay

2:00 AM on 05.11.2013

Ghost in the Shell: ARISE gets a dramatic trailer

Despite some odd design choices, I'm actually really looking forward to the upcoming Ghost in the Shell: ARISE OVAs. I've been a huge fan of the franchise since I was a kid, and I was thrilled to here we'd be getting mo...

Elliot Gay

6:00 PM on 05.09.2013

What does the JET expansion mean for Japan?

A few days ago, Josh brought word that the ruling Japanese political party, the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP), is planning to more than double the JET program over the next three years. All of this is part of Prime Minister ...

Brad Rice

12:43 AM on 05.09.2013

Have a look at some Kill-La-Kill character designs

Thanks to the power of people on the internet getting things early, we now have a really fantastic look at some of the character designs for Trigger's Kill-La-Kill. Directed by Hiroyuki Imaishi and written by Kazuki Nakashima...

Elliot Gay

5:15 AM on 05.08.2013

Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! 2nd season confirmed

Thanks to an early Newtype leak, we now have confirmation that KyoAni's wacky romantic comedy, Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai!, is in fact getting a second sequel. While we knew a new project was underway, there was some specu...

Elliot Gay

4:37 AM on 05.08.2013

Trigger's new TV anime is called Kill-La-Kill

After much teasing, Trigger, the masterminds behind the excellent Little Witch Academia, have unveiled their newest project. Kill-La-Kill is a TV anime (two cours) directed by Hiroyuki Imaishi (Gurren Lagann, Dead Leaves, FLC...

Elliot Gay




Facebook Shares





From other sites around the web
















Back to Top



Advertising on Japanator is available: Please contact them to learn more