Quantcast
Japanator (kinda) Recommends: Blade of the Phantom Master: Shin Angyo Onshi - JAPANATOR
DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist


REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll


Japanator (kinda) Recommends: Blade of the Phantom Master: Shin Angyo Onshi


9:15 PM on 07.30.2009
Japanator (kinda) Recommends: Blade of the Phantom Master: Shin Angyo Onshi photo



How many manga (or in this case, Korean manwha) can you recall that use the following formula:

1. Take a legendary figure or epic adventure

2. Twist it to become dark and gritty or something, then cast it as a seinen series

3.  ???

4. Profit!!!

I'd bet that you can think of a whole bunch. This film version of Blade of the Phantom Master is just like those, only it doesn't have the advantage of being, y'know, a series. Read on for more of why that makes it so sad.

Blade of the Phantom Master: Shin Angyo Onshi
Based on the manwha by In-Wan Youn,
Distributed by FUNimation

As per the formula above, and like the manwha it's adapted from, Blade of the Phantom Master draws from Korean myths and folk-tales to form the foundation of its otherwise fantastic world. Greatest among these is The Legend of Chun-Hyang, the events of which more or less inspire the first half of the film.

Amen-Osa were once secret agents of the now-toppled Jushin empire, traveling the world to investigate evildoers and corrupt rulers, summoning phantom soldiers from their medallions to deliver violent retribution. With the collapse of the kingdom, the Amen-Osa were left to wander, one of them being Munsu, the protagonist.

Almost as soon as the film begins one can detect the anti-heroic twists applied to the old stories. Munsu encounters Monlyon, the original hero of the Chun-Hyang legend. Like the legend, Monlyon intended to become a royal inspector (in this case an Amen-Osa) to punish the warlord that kidnapped his lover. However, barely ten minutes in, Monlyon is killed horribly by sand cannibals, and Munsu is forced to use his corpse as a shield from their arrows, eventually exchanging it for safe passage. Hardly a fitting image for the champion of justice that most commoners (including poor Monlyon) thought Amen-Osa to be.

Eventually, the events of the Chun-Hyang legend come to pass, with Munsu passing bloody judgment upon the warlord and freeing Monlyon's lover. But rather than a delicate bride, Chun-Hyang turns out to be a crazy swordsman dressed in a leather S&M getup and rocking a giant clawed fist.

And so it goes on. The show plays with its stereotypes and figures in a fashion not unlike that of Saiyuki, retelling heroic journeys in an antiheroic way. Unfortunately, that's where this film falls on its face. Being a film, it's simply incapable of expanding upon the wealth of material already available in the manwha series. The second half of the movie is a new adventure, with seemingly no connection to the first half, other than featuring both Munsu and Chun-Hyang, who followed him, acting as his Sando bodyguard (and renaming herself same).

The same goes for the art. While well-animated and boasting a satisfying level of choreographed bloodshed, the  film doesn't carry over the deep shading and complex details of the manwha that called to mind such classics as Berserk and the more recent Tenjoh Tenge and Claymore manga. 

As such, the entire movie feels like a 90-minute pilot episode for TV series that would never be (it's been five years since the original debut). Which is quite a shame, since it would have made a great long-running show.

In the end, the best thing you can do for Blade of the Phantom Master is to rent it, and then read the manwha, which was featured in Japanator's own Scanlation Spotlight column back in February.

Japanator (kinda) Recommends: Blade of the Phantom Master: Shin Angyo Onshi photo
Japanator (kinda) Recommends: Blade of the Phantom Master: Shin Angyo Onshi photo
Japanator (kinda) Recommends: Blade of the Phantom Master: Shin Angyo Onshi photo





Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.

Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


that's kinda disappointing. Just finished reading the series, and I loved the story. But sometimes people just get good source material and can't do it justice (*glare* at valkyria chronicles anime...)
I remember looking this up when Len made the scanlation spotlight back in the day. The anime wasn't able to capture the manhwa art style which was its biggest disappointment.
It's very hard to translate the highly detailed style of the manga to animation (not to mention this movie is five years old), maybe it could be done with today's technology?

I do agree story-wise like it falls short. The movie is more like eye-candy for the people who were already reading the manga than anything stand-alone.

10:48 AM on 05.15.2013

Watch a FUNi employee go insane catching up to One Piece

Ah, the things people do for One Piece. And for marketing One Piece. Oda-sensei's great pirate baby is heading back to Cartoon Network's Toonami block, much to the rejoicing of nostalgic fans. It's not exactly going to be on ...

Josh Tolentino

2:00 PM on 05.07.2013

Celebrate Mother's Day with free Wolf Children cards

Have you been fretting over what to get your dear Mom this year for Mother's Day? Better hurry up, as it's this Sunday, and you're running out of time! If you're strapped for cash, and not sure how to show Mom you care, Funim...

Hiroko Yamamura

10:10 PM on 05.06.2013

Gattai: FUNimation's divisions combine into a new group

Oh hey, this sounds interesting. It looks like FUNimation is going to consolidate their divisions into a new group known as Group 1200 Media. Under this new name, Group 1200 Media plans to release other forms of entertainment...

Salvador G-Rodiles

10:00 AM on 04.18.2013

Review: A Certain Magical Index Season 1

Before I took on the task of watching A Certain Magical Index, I was told that the series evolves into one giant convoluted mess. With the exception of a few terms, the show’s first season doesn't feature anyt...

Salvador G-Rodiles

12:00 PM on 04.10.2013

Red Data Girl stream starts over at Funimation tonight

Red Data Girl may have already started airing in Japan last week, but if you've been waiting to watch the P.A. Works show, you're in luck. Funimation will begin airing the show starting tonight! Hulu subscribers, that means y...

Hiroko Yamamura

6:00 PM on 04.09.2013

First Impressions: Hataraku Maou-sama!

Another entry in the increasingly large parade of "Demon King" anime, Hataraku Maou-sama! - FUNimation is streaming the show as The Devil Is A Part-Timer!, a name that seems to imply a different but equally int...

Josh Tolentino

2:00 PM on 03.25.2013

A lot of people tuned into Toonami for the Eva movie

It looks like Toonami had a pretty good evening last week, when it returned to its late night programming block. In fact, close to a million people tuned in to the Neon Genesis Evangelion: You are (not) Alone movie airing. Bo...

Hiroko Yamamura

1:00 PM on 03.11.2013

Review: Sengoku Basara: Samurai Kings - The Last Party

Under normal circumstances, it’s not advisable for one to jump into a continuing series without experiencing its earlier installments. While I broke this rule with Sengoku Basara: Samurai Kings - The Last Party, my...

Salvador G-Rodiles

12:00 PM on 03.11.2013

Evangelion 1.11 will air on Toonami this weekend

Loyal Toonami fans have a reason to stay in this weekend... well more reason than usual. Funimation has just released information at MomoCon that US television premiere of Neon Genesis Evangelion: 1.11 Yo...

Hiroko Yamamura

1:00 PM on 02.19.2013

Turbulence: FUNi's Last Exile FAM box sets get delayed

Well, it looks like FUNimation's release of Last Exile - FAM, The Silver Wing took a wrong turn off of the designated flight path. But no need to fear, since they are only facing a minor delay in FAM's release date.  Ins...

Salvador G-Rodiles




Facebook Shares





From other sites around the web
















Back to Top



Advertising on Japanator is available: Please contact them to learn more