Gundam SEED and G Gundam are the two WORST Gundam shows out there. I'll take 08th MS Team or Zeta Gundam over those series any day.
I absolutely love The Girl Who Leapt Through Time though.
It's a shame to see so many great series being left way back on the ranking though. Hopefully I'm forgetting some really epic shows that deserve to be in the top #30.
Also Moyashimon is pretty low if you ask me :(
Yeah. I thought Gundam SEED was one of the more hated yet popular due to mass exposure Gundam series out there. I'm personally not much of a fan of the series at all since it's still pretty 70s camp but with modern tropes but in terms of all-time mecha series it's pretty integral to the anime canon.
Also, excellent list so far. You may as well rename it Japanator's recommendations for the decade.
*ahem* Interesting picks so far. Nice to see Ouran there. Hate to admit it but it's one of the few Shoujos that I really enjoy. Quite a few I didn't expect, but I can see the reasoning behind the choices...except for Gundam SEED of course.
Oh and The Girl Who Lept Through Time is truly amazing. A bit sad its not higher on the list.
Check out my c-blog to view my comments in all their disgusting glory.
Feel free to rage and insult me personally for dissing your favorite show.
Moyashimon was a show that was hard to describe. I had a great time watching it, wouldn't say I LOVED it, but I definitely didn't hate it. Just simple fun. Honestly, I didnt think it would become a hit or even something much talked about. But with how much I hear about it on the 'net these days, I'm really surprised it hasnt been licensed yet.
That said, while I'm happy to see a lot of my favorite shows on this list, I'm surprised to find a number of them at the bottom 20. And seriously, Moyashimon out-ranking Mushishi? Now that's a crime :/
I can see your point, and it seems you're mostly correct as the list so far contains 16 things from the latter half of this decade (2005-2009) versus 4 things from 2000-2004.
But then we should also include properties from 2000-2004 in the bottom half of list that were relatively good at the time but not memorable enough in the long run.
All in all, no list is perfect it's impossible to create a list that suits everyone's tastes, but the discussion that such lists can sprout are fun in their own right :)
Here here! Exactly what I'm sticking around for! ;)
Also, must watch Kannagi to see if I agree with it's placement over Bakemonogatari
The plotline is blatantly ripped of from Original Gundam. For the majority of the series the plot mirrors the original Gundams storyline very closely. It isnt until later in the series that the plot diverges from the original story.
It's not that it was great. It's quite simple really. A simple basic show, but it was arguably the 'first' of it's kind. Some say it started the whole harem-explosion. It set a formula how many of the harem's today work. It also was a huge gateway-show, opening the doors of anime to many of today's current fans.
So while it's a great show for me personally, since it was my first, I see where others would have just found it decent, perhaps generic, or maybe not like it at all. I couldn't really recommend it to a new/recent anime fan, as it might not hold up as well as a fan such as myself would think. I'm sure it might seem dated and sloppy.
But in 2000/2001 whenever it hit, it was a solid story with solid characters that introduced new things.
Actually, now that I think about it, I see many similarities with Ranma (which I love), with the over the top characters and immensely improbable situations. Still, a good show nonetheless.
Which more and more I think about it, this list will have a lot of included. Including items not so much for the story of the specific show, but for how the industry reacted to them, positively or negatively, sales, etc. Which is why I wouldn't be surprised to see Gurren Lagann or K-On! higher up on the list, where many people are wishing for them not to fall.
Whether an individual liked them or not, they were hype machines that got people excited. People were in love with Mio weeks/month before the first episode even aired. She was a force to be reckoned with, which IMO it deserves a spot on the list for alone. Gurren Lagann was an epic that made fun of epics. I don't understand the hate on that one at all.

Rising (3+)
People you follow



































follow