DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist


Lolis to be censored (or not) in Japan by March 30th photo

The time has come. The "Youth Nurturing and Protection Ordinance," a proposal to essentially censor images of "childlike" characters in media, is set to enter committee on March 18th. Should the bill move through that, it will be placed before the Diet for a vote on March 30th, taking effect as early as October.

Mangaka Yoshitoshi ABe had this to say on his blog:

Simply put, even for characters of a story who do not actually exist, and even those who are portrayed not as minors but as adult figures, sales of works in which the panties of these characters can be seen can be restricted if you have a hunch that they appear childlike, for one thing; and more generally, it is an unconstitutional and ridiculous piece of legislation. I’m not talking about children’s books. I mean mass market publications, anime, games, and all manners of works. Both Doraemon and Sazae-san are right out!

The full post was translated by Shii of welcome datacomp, and is available for reading there. I strongly suggest that you go and read up, because it's a doozy. 



MOAR ZOMGWTFBBQ:




Legacy Comments

Draconian and stupid this may be, all I can think is "Ha! Moe-bullshit, checkmate!"
It'll never come to pass.
So, Doraemon is moe bullshit?
I saw this coming it was just a matter of when but, yeah "Ha! Moe-bullshit, checkmate" those are just about right
words*
ffff this means stuff like kannagi and zero no has to get censored, like 15% of all anime/manga, probibly more but i dont wanna just throw out a random huge number
@Phantomile

hope your right
Now this make me very conflicted. As much as I am for freedom and anti censorship I can't help but the glad that the entire loli crap might,tho' highly unlikely, go away. Ever since this issue come into discussion there has been an explosion of all things loli, just to prove a point kinda, which only make me side, even more, with the bad people. Damn you loli for making me a hypocrite!
No fucking way would this be allowed to pass.
As long as Shin-chan showing off his junk is popular, I doubt this will go very far.
soon all our anime characters will have wrinkles... because anyone thats not old and act childish can be seen as "childlike"... well done -.-
This won't stop moe. This has very little to do with moe.
What if someone draws a character who is a 'female' robot, who has small breasts and a big head and is said in the story to be over 20 years old, and shows her panties.

Is that going to be illegal?

What if the character didn't wear panties, but had a pelvic body structure which was coloured like panties.

Where is it all going to end?

This isn't a law about real effects of porn or artistic depictions, it is about the different ideas in people's heads. Anyone can imagine anything, and other people can imagine something completely different in the same situation.
Hi all, first ever post and all that so thanks for having me. Saddens me to start on a down note but, to all those who think this idiot law will never pass, I only hope you're right. Britain has just sleepwalked into passing a law that is the exact duplicate of this. Posession of any depiction of minors, or people who 'can be reasonably assumed' to be minors - irrespective of whatever age the artist/author depicts them as, or fantasy figures/creatures who might be taken to resemble minors engaged in or included in the same image as sexual acts (are you following this?) can now get you three years in prison. And this includes depictions of 16/17 year olds, i.e. people who can have sex legally In The Real World - a place the authors of this kind of legislation don't seem to frequent too often. This country truly is a madhouse. I'd imagined Japan would remain immune from this hysterical BS but seems like the writing is on the wall. Sad, sad world we live in...
Wow, allot of people will be pissed if this passed. Would boost dvd sales though.
I hope it won't pass. This somewhat turns into a USSR censorship system. Or maybe Saudi Arabia? Or Australia? In a word it is a surpresion of freedom of expresion.
I want the over protective moms who came up with this (and i realize that is just mere speculation and wishful thinking....but you get the point) to be flayed in the streets. I understand the sentiments behind this law, and I also appreciate the over all intent. At this point though all it is is people's fears over child molestation snowballing into something that is totally different. The sad thing is, the people who are coming up with these laws actually believe that censoring "child-like" characters in anime and manga would bring an end to the issue. There's always going to be a huge number of fans of the loli genre, the preference is as old as human civilization (not saying its a good part about it). One law like this won't do anything but stir up people's rebellious attitudes towards it. If nothing else this will just increase the amount of underground loli output.
If they pass this law and Yotsuba&! is hurt because of it, I cannot guarantee a safer Japan.

Alternatively, if this stops the horribly scarring pictures of Yotsuba on gelbooru, then go ahead.
We should make it illegal for minors to commit sexual acts. Oh wait since they are minors they cannot be tried as adults. Hmmm... but in the 16-17 range would the exception be made to try them as adults as in most homicide cases? And i do not believe it is the currently targeted or censored material that is having an influence on their lustful sins of the flesh. It is the media that makes it past the censorship that is corrupting them. I don't listen to the radio because all the stations are playing songs with obvious sexual undertones to much T&A.

Then that would also mean that even if the person is legally 18 but since their genetic makeup makes them look younger than they really are should be barred from pornography. Yes she's 18. then why does she look like she's 13??
Bye bye, yaoi!
As it does pass, I hope a riot would break out!
OMG are they trying to destroy all of Akihabara??? Girls that are lolis or look like lolis...

So Shana, Taiga, Louise, RUKIA? The Higurashi Girls? Nanoha, Fate, Vivio and Vita (o_o) Or gasp - even Nagato Yuki? Or Rei Ayanami? DONT take away KUROKO (=_=)

Rie Kugiyama, Yukari Tamura, and Nana Mizuki are going to be out of work soon...

Someone Tell ZUN to start drawing his Touhou Girls with BREASTS and not wear pa....*Gets Knifed*
This bill doesn't even appear to be about loli porn drawings or whatever...it says any character that looks as if it might be under 18 and might be "sexually provocative." That is a far, far cry from being specifically about lolicon stuff. It's a totally crazy law if I ever heard one, regardless of what kind of cartoons you like or why you watch/read them.
@0216332 A couple of years later that won't be viable too, since it would exploit the poor defenseless elderly population.
SCREW THEM! LOLIS FTW
A sad day truly. If you think about it, it is the same with gun control bills, by saying it is not people that kill people, but guns that kill people thus by getting rid of guns you will automatically solve the problem, but if you really wanted to kill somebody you can stab him/her to death with your mechanical pencil as long as the desire is great enough. Thus by the same reasoning: by censoring or getting rid of all things loli, like innocent fan service shots, this will automatically solve the problem with child molesters. For it is not molesters that molest children but loli images.
This won't pass. Additionally , despite the fact that I don't even like loli, I would start deliberately breaking this law, in an act of civil disobedience. This is just stupid and a sign of feminazi influence.
Soooo...here's how dumb people are in my Sex Offenses class. A girl asked the teacher "So child porn is okay in Japan?!" I wanted to punch her in the face. And the teacher, who claims to have worked with the FBI said he DID NOT KNOW. I call BS.

Because anime and manga is STILL all porn is some retards minds. And now includes live children!
Soooo...here's how dumb people are in my Sex Offenses class. A girl asked the teacher "So child porn is okay in Japan?!" I wanted to punch her in the face. And the teacher, who claims to have worked with the FBI said he DID NOT KNOW. I call BS.

Because anime and manga is STILL all porn is some retards minds. And now includes live children!
*BANGS HEAD AGAINST WALL*
I'm supposed to be writing a paper for that class by the way. It's due tomorrow.
@ShaggyTheOnly That's what I often think while looking at stuff like pencils, beauty products, my keys... I mean people can ban whatever they want, but it won't change the fact that as you said people are the ones who kill people and not the object used for it.
hey ShaggyTheOnly

Remember laws are there only for law abiding citizens. Those who commit crimes will continue to commit crimes regardless of law. I agree these laws do little to solve the true problems while law makers use silly facades to garner public outcry support. Unfortunately majority of public is very impressionable and ignorant. I'd say life in prison without parole for child molesters, i hear the hardened criminals don't take lightly child molesters. Permanent revocation of licence if involved in a DUI or DWI severe injury or fatality of another person. Why? lets see sure life is difficult without a license but it's more than being DEAD. And choices were made and consequences occurred and 正義 JUSTICE must be served
Well i for one didn't ask to have the laws of this society forced upon me.i mean they can try and enforce this ridiculous crap on us if they like but short of some buff guy with an axe looming over me 24/7 making sure i dont do it there's nothing they can do to stop me.Pssh its always the same,they say this is now unacceptable behavior and then we say whatever and do it any way.my point is that even if this pathetic law somehow goes through it wont stop me and my comrades from loving loli shota and seeking it out/creating it in any way we can.BTW im seventeen and live in Australia where lolicon is supposedly banned SO SUCK IT GOVERNMENT.
oh god we're turning into australia...
this will never ever pass if it does all hell will break out
I can't understand the reason of censoring these anime movies too. Do they seduce our kids or what? I mean I have watched few series just to be sure if my kid is safe and I have seen absolutely nothing wrong in those movies. I will let my kid watch them in the future too.
Best wishes, Greg from payday loans online


Facebook Shares





Around the web