Quantcast
games  anime  toys  movies
Japanator is anime news, community, videos & geeky J-stuff. Updated daily!   Sign up to comment or blog    |    Returning? Login

japanator logo

Weekly Otaku Debate: Nodame Cantabile vs Hana Yori Dango
by Tim Sheehy, 10/07/2009
Weekly Otaku Debate: Nodame Cantabile vs Hana Yori Dango photo

Considering the scope of the last debate, I thought it'd be fair to give it a bit extra time. After all, I felt it'd be pretty tough to choose just one of Miyazaki's masterpieces. Sure enough, some of you couldn't pick just one. Some of you guys are really passionate about your Howl's Moving Castle and Princess Mononoke though.

Incase you're wondering, Princess Mononoke won. Still, if you haven't seen any of those films, you should do yourself a favor and read some of those comments. They might just make you want to see the films you've missed out on.

Kiki's Delivery Service - 6 votes
Nausica: Valley of the Wind - 7 votes
My Neighbor Totoro - 10 votes
Spirited Away - 8 votes
Princess Mononoke - 13 votes
Laputa: Castle in the Sky - 4 votes
Howl's Moving Castle - 10 votes
Ponyo - 1 vote
Porco Rosso - 6 votes
Lupin the 3rd: The Castle of Cagliostro  - 3 votes

Hit the jump for the next debate!

I've secretly been wanting to do a J-Drama debate for months now but I've held off. I suppose I was so hesitant because I wasn't sure how many of you have really given J-Dramas a try yet--you're a fool if you haven't, by the way.

However, after much thought, and a little prodding at the behest of Colette, I've come to the conclusion that you've probably seen these shows. Even if you haven't, you've probably read the manga or watched the anime they were based on so you should have a point of reference for this. Both of these dramas were hugely successful, spawning multiple seasons, specials, and a theatrical film.

Hana Yori Dango is a story about a girl from a working-class family who ends up at a high school for the rich elite, practically ran by the four heirs to the wealthiest families in Japan. After initially being picked on, she develops a unique relationship with the four heirs which blossoms into a love triangle.

Nodame Cantabile is a story about two students who attend a music academy. A quirky young woman who lives a very disorganized life, and refuses to read sheet music, instead playing by ear, and her antithesis--a man who prides himself on being an absolute perfectionist with the secret ambition of becoming a conductor. While he remains driven toward his goal of becoming the next famous Japanese conductor, she strives to capture his heart. Check out Colette's write up if you want to learn more about it.

I adored both of these series, though I'm a tad partial to Hana Yori Dango myself. It's kind of strange too, considering I dealt with learning classical piano almost exactly like Nodame did.  I guess the memories of that weren't all that pleasant for me, and despite the humor, I found it bringing up some bad memories. Which of these shows was your favorite though?






About our new comments system

We're evaluating Livefyre, a new comments system that helps us fight spam, allows you to thread comments, get email notifications, and follow site-wide AND twitter/facebook conversations about our stories all from one page. If you love it we will integrate it into the site permanently so that your old comments and profiles sync up. During this test you can register a chat avatar and track your comments here. Let us know what you think! support@japanator.com

Embedding images/pictures: To help us fight spam/pr0n we only support images from Flickr, Twitpic, tinypic, and imgur for images. Just type in the URL and a thumbnail of the picture will show up. Supported video sources are vimeo and youtube.

Legacy comments:

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 


 

Anime news got news? tips@japanator.com


Manga news

Community Blogs   + post a blog   view all














TEAM

Editor-in-Chief
Brad Rice

News Editor
Josh Tolentino

Reviews Editor
Hiroko Yamamura

Associate Editors
Dale North
Zac Bentz
Jeff Chuang
Pedro Cortes
Bob Muir
Kristina Pino
Marc Speer
Elliot Gay Chris Walden Salvador G-Rodiles Michelle Rodanes

Made by
ModernMethod






about us and privacy policy